Article 46C.154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
provides that the court “may not inform a juror . . . of the consequences
to the defendant if a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity
is returned.” Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 46C.154.
This obviously precludes an instruction informing jurors specifically
of the procedural steps that follow such a verdict.
It is less clear whether the statute bars a trial court from
instructing a jury to give no consideration to what will happen
to the defendant in the event of such a verdict. It is possible
that the provision may permit an instruction that the jurors should
simply assume that the legislature has made adequate provision for
defendants so acquitted.
The Committee concluded that the propriety of any instruction
on the matter is so unclear and the wisdom in such dispute that
it would not recommend that the instruction address the matter.
Comment
Article 46C.154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that the court “may not inform a juror . . . of the consequences to the defendant if a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity is returned.” Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 46C.154. This obviously precludes an instruction informing jurors specifically of the procedural steps that follow such a verdict.
It is less clear whether the statute bars a trial court from instructing a jury to give no consideration to what will happen to the defendant in the event of such a verdict. It is possible that the provision may permit an instruction that the jurors should simply assume that the legislature has made adequate provision for defendants so acquitted.
The Committee concluded that the propriety of any instruction on the matter is so unclear and the wisdom in such dispute that it would not recommend that the instruction address the matter.